Top Courses and More

Reviews and feedback for courses and other game content.
SteveHorn
Legend of Golf
Posts: 1100
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 8:24 am

Top Courses and More

Post by SteveHorn »

I've decided to post a list of my current course ratings over the past 4 seasons of tournament play. I still have MANY courses that I haven't played in the last 4 seasons so they of course aren't rated. Its only the past 4 seasons that I've offically kept track of ratings of my own.
Each season I roughly play 50 percent of the tournaments with courses that have never been played in tournament mode. I'm asking for the communities help in deciding what unplayed course's I should play in the upcoming season. I have several Hundred on disk that have yet to be played in a tournament. Input and comments welcome.

MY CURRENT TOP ELEVEN COURSE’S

#1 Coastal Links at Edisto Island (9.9 A+)
#2 Arcaida Bluffs (9.9 A+)
#3 North American Woods (9.9 A+)
#4 Point Reyes National (9.85 A+)
#5 Mill Creek G.C. (9.85 A+)
#6 Stone Pony (9.85 A+)
#7 The Lakes Course at Pine Ridge (9.85 A+)
#8 Glen Haven (9.8 A)
#9 Coo's Bay (9.8 A)
#10 Stormbay (9.8 A)
#11 The Trenche at Monticello (9.8 A)

Tournament Course’s Ratings
A- A Horse with No Name (9.5 B+) Abernathy Estates (9.6 A-) Albatross G.R. (9.7 A) Alkimos
G. L. (9.6 A-) All American G.C. (9.5 B+) Arcadia Bluffs (9.9 A+) Arcadia G.L. Old Course (9.2 X)
Armegeddon (9.35 B) Arrowhead (9.6 A-) Augusta National 2001 (9.7 A) Autumn Winds G.L.
(9.4 B)
B- Badlands (9.3 B-) Barton Creek (9.55 A-) Bay Hill Palmer Course (9.15 X) Bay Shore Links
(9.6 A-) Bayview Hills (9.65 A-) Bethpage Black (9.6 A-) Bish Memorial (9.55 A-) Blackwood G.C.
(9.6 A-) Blake Valley (9.55 A-) Blue Mountains G.C. (9.6 A-) Booneyville Mountain (9.5 B+)
Bushwacker (9.6 A-)
C- Cades Cove (9.7 A) Canterbury (9.65 A-) Carnoustie (9.65 A-) Carolina Cottonmouth (9.7 A)
Carolindi Forest (9.5 B+) Castle Stuart (9.7 A) Champions Course at Cumberland (9.7 A)
Coastal Links at Edisto Island (9.9 A+) Colonial C.C.(9.4 B) Congressional (9.5 B+) Coo’s Bay
G.L. (9.8 A) Copyright Club G.R. (9.45 B+) Coronas the Gold Course 2010 (9.45 B+) Cougills
Keep G.C. (9.6 A-) Crook O’Lune (9.45 B+) Crooked Run Golf & C.C. (9.35 B) Cypress Bay
Resort (9.65 A-)
D- Danish Greens (9.65 A-) Danish Mermaid G.C. (9.4 B) Debien Fields (9.55 A-) Deception
Point (9.55 A-) Defiant Heart C.C. (9.55 A-) Del Bocca Vista (9.4 B) Desert Edge (9.2 X) Desert
Shores (9.4 B) Desierto de Tejas (9.6 A-) Destiny Ridge (9.65 A-) Dogwood Trail C.E (9.75 A)
Dragon Ridge (9.5 B+) Death Valley (9.35 B)
E- Erins Glade (9.7 A)
F- Firestone - South (9.6 A-)
G- Glen Haven (9.8 A) Glendale C.C. (9.6 A-) Gleneagle (9.75 A) Great Pond (9.6 A-)
Gunpowder Bay (9.4 B) Gut Kaden (9.75 A)
H- Hawks Nest (9.35 B) Hideaway Haven (9.35 B) Hummingbird Haven (9.35 B)
I- Innsbrook Copperhead (9.6 A-)
J- Joshua Ridge (9.6 A-)
K- Kapalua Plantation Course (9.75 A) Kauais Kekaha G.C. (9.5 B+) Kewadin Prairie Lodge
(9.45 B+) Kilmory Links (9.45 B+) Kingston Heath (9.35 B) Knotty Pines (9.6 A-)
L- Lake Evelyn C.C. (9.45 B+) Lake Lavon (9.75 A) Lakeland G.C. (9.6 A-) Lakeland Hills (9.5
B-) Laurentain Hills (9.4 B) Lighthouse Bay (9.7 A) Links at Donofrio Bay (9.65 A-) Links at
Rugged Dunes (9.6 A-) Links Course at Hatteras Isle (9.65 A-) Lochiel G.L. (9.45 B+)
M- Machette (9.6 A-) Mae’s Glen (9.65 A-) Majestic Woods C.C. (9.35 B ) Makossa (9.5 B+)
Mamacs Retreat (9.6 A-) Maple Hills @ Mosquito Creek (9.45 B+) Mayfield Manor G.C. (9.6 A-
) Medina #3 (9.6 A-) Mill Creek G.C. (9.85 A+) Mohican Valley (9.65 A-) Muirfield (9.4 B) Muirfield
Village 2011 (9.7 A)
N- North American Woods (9.9 A+) North Cheshire G.C. (9.55 A-)
O- Oak Hill (9.45 B+) Oakmont (9.35 B) Old Mission (9.4 B) Osprey Resort & G.C. (9.45 B+)
P- Parkland Creek (9.55 A-) Pebble Beach (9.6 A-) Pine Anchor (9.6 A-) Pine Crest C. C. (9.55
A-) Pine Haven (east) (9.7 A) Pine Haven (west) (9.7 A) Pinebrook Plantation (9.6 A-)
Pinehurst #2 (9.5 B+) PGA National (9.5 B+) Point Counterpoint (9.6 A-) Point Reyes National
(9.85 A+) Poppy Hills (9.6 A-)
Q- Quail Hollow V-2 (9.3 B-)
R- Red Dragon (9.55 A-) Riveria C.C. (9.5 B+) Royal Litham - St Annes (9.55 A-) Royal
Liverpool – Hoylake (9.55 A-) Royal Valley Rameses (9.4 B) Royal St. George (9.65 A-)
S- Sawtooth (9.6 A-) Schuberts Bay (9.7 A) Shani Lake (9.3 B-) Shammrock Shores (9.7 A)
Seasons (9.3 B-) Stone Pony (9.85 A+) Stormbay (9.8 A) Sundance (9.45 B+)
T- The Communities Course (9.7 A) The C.C. at Terra Cotta Plantation (9.7 A) The Diamond
(9.4 B) The Devil @ Dusk (9.55 A-) The Diggins (9.7 A) The Dunes (9.6 A-) The Lakes Course @
PineRidge (9.85 A+) The Monterey Club (9.4 B-) The Monument (9.7 A-) The Old Course St.
Andrews (9.35 B) TheOld Course St Andrews 2010 (9.65 A-) The Platinum Course at Stoney
Hills C.C. (9.65 A-) The Trenche at Monticello (9.8 A) The Tullyboothy Craigs (9.45 B+) The
Valley Course at Horseshoe Bend (9.7 A) Tidewater G.C. & Plantation (9.55 A-) Tomahawk Run
(9.7 A) TPC River Highlands (9.4 B) TPC Sawgrass (9.55 A-) TPC Sawgrass 2010 (9.7 A) TPC
Scottsdale (9.5 B+) TPC Southwind 2010 (9.65 A-) TPC Waterloo (9.35 B) 2002 TPC White
Sands (9.75 A)
U- Ullna G.K. (9.55 A-) Upstate C.C. (9.6 A)
V- Valhalla (9.1 X)
W- Waialae C.C. (9.6 A-) Westchester C.C. (9.55 A-) Whispering Ridge (9.4 B) Whitsunday
Island (9.5 B+) Wildside (9.6 A-) Woodland Hills (9.6 A-) Wookey Hollow (9.6 A-)
X-
Y-
Z-
Last edited by SteveHorn on November 7th, 2014, 9:35 am, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

Here are my A listers not showing on your list.

Alice Boges Garden CC
Apache Pass
Arrowhead (Cliffs)
Arrowhead McHale
Aspiration Valley
Atchafalaya Basin
Autumn Estates
Aveley Island
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

And my B's.

Bad Axe
Bali Shandra
Ballybunion GC
Baltusrol
Barneget Bay GC
Barren Hills
Billabong Sanctuary
Birdsong GC
Bish Memorial
Blackheath GC
Blackstone National
Blue Lagoon
Bogey Hills
Boston Hills
Boundry Waters
British Isle Golf Club
Brookgreen
Bullock Run
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

C's.

Casa Bella Golf Course
Castle Ridge
Castle Rock
CC at Terra Cotta Plantation
Cezannes Sanctuary
Champions Club
Chebona Bula
Chetramont Golf & CC
Cheviot Run Inland Links
Cheyenne County Country Club
Chilton Hills GC
Chinook North Championship Course
Chinook North Members Course
Clarkston CC
Cliff Course at Mosteller Island
Club de Campo de las Lomas de Esperanza
Club De Golf Valderamma V2
Copperhead
Country Club of Martin Downs
Creek Fields
Crescent Hills
Cripple Creek Resort
Crop Circle Canyon
Cybele Ridge
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

Only 3 D's.

Doral Blue Course
Driftwood
Dunes Golf Resort
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

E & F.

Eagles Cry
Eight Lakes CC
English Turn
European Country Club
European Links
Evermore Valley
Excaliber
Festival GC
Fir Lakes Country Club
Flinders Range
Forest of the Hills
Forrest Highlands Canyon Course
Forrest Oaks
Four Lakes Preserve
Fox Den GC - Stow, Ohio
Franklin Lakes
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

This is where I'm up to, still playing my way through the H's.

G&CC Schlaubetal
Gaia Hills
Gatcombe Creek
Glenmarnock
Gloucester
Grand Harbor Links
Granite Course at the Foothills
Granite Hollow
Grass Valley GC
Greenbrier Resort (Pete Dye)
Greenbrier The
Greenville Castle GC
Greywolf Run
Grizzly Summit
SteveHorn
Legend of Golf
Posts: 1100
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 8:24 am

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by SteveHorn »

David ! Thanks for the input. Thats alot of courses but I'd like you to narrow it down to 3 to 5 on which courses I should play in the up coming season. No guarantee's that I'll play them all. They must be on my pre list and meet yardage requirement. Minimum yardage isn't all that long because of the way the game does yardage for doglegs but there are a few that don't qualify. Also a few on your list are already on my played list.
Last edited by SteveHorn on October 31st, 2014, 8:07 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Polslad
Legend of Golf
Posts: 528
Joined: November 18th, 2010, 12:24 pm

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by Polslad »

Steve,
I'm currently playing every course on Dars A list, as my season tour venues.
My personal performance may have suffered in making cuts and winning, but I sure am getting to play a LOT of courses that I hadn't considered.
I've got about 230 to go, and then I plan to revisit all the ones I rate as A+ courses.
BrianZ111
Legend of Golf
Posts: 1025
Joined: November 12th, 2010, 12:59 pm
Location: Wisconsin
Contact:

Re: Top Courses and More

Post by BrianZ111 »

What's your yardage cut off? I know most of my courses probably aren't long enough but I'm curious if Bull's Eye makes the cut. I'm working a version of it for WGC where I'll probably add some additional fictitious back tees on some holes to accommodate for the 300 yard drives in that game. I'd be curious if you think I should port these tees over to the updated PGA version I'll finish later as well.
Post Reply